The various GameStop stickers I peeled off the game I bought (chronologically top to bottom)

I found the first one they had under the black sticker the most interesting, having bought a "used" copy online only to see a "defective return" sticker. Was this "refurbished"? Replaced? Did somebody lie about a defect for a return?

Already installed, so it works fine, thankfully.

Excited to finally play it!